

Aren’t these great? I ran across them a few months ago in Better Homes and Garden and thought they were the cutest. I knew we had this series coming up and thought they would work perfect for the Thanksgiving alternatives theme. So if you are signed up for the pie this year, show up with these little guys in all sorts of flavors and no one will have to feel too bad about having 3 different pieces of pie!
In the article they shared a pie filling recipe, but for simplicity I went with a good canned apple one. Also if you have a pie crust you just love to use, knock yourself out!
Pie On A Stick
adapted from BHG Sept 2010 issue, pg 212Ingredients:
1 15-oz pkg refrigerated pie crust (2 crusts)
10-12 paper or wooden lollipop sticks
Your favorite pie filling (I cut the apples in mine to be just little then mashed with a fork a bit)
1 egg, separated
1 tablespoon sugar
1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
1/4 teaspoon nutmeg
Preparation:
- Preheat oven to 375°. If not using a nonstick cookie sheet line with parchment paper and set aside.
- Unroll the pie crusts on a lightly floured surface. Roll each crust to be about a 12 inch circle. Using a leaf cookie cutter or circle (mine was around 3 inches and I found it at Hobby Lobby) make 10 – 12 cutouts from each crust.
- Put half the cutouts on the baking sheet and press the lollipop sticks into the center of each. Spoon a little filling into the middle of each.
- Take your egg white and add a teaspoon of water, whisk until frothy. With your finger brush the egg white on the edges of the cutouts. Place the other cutouts onto the filling and with a fork seal the edges. Make sure the dough is pressed firmly around the stick.
- Whisk the egg yolk and a teaspoon of water in a small bowl. Brush onto the top of the pies. Combine the sugar, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Sprinkle over the top of the pies.
- Bake for 15 -20 minutes or until golden. Let cool on baking sheet.

A few notes on making the pies. To fit more filling into my pies I molded the top piece a bit in my fingers to be a dome. That way you get more filling with the crust. Speaking of the crust, if it seems a little thin, that is okay. You don’t want it too thick or your pies will be all crust!

I was surprised how well they bonded to the stick, I was worried they would be wobbly, but they turned out nice and sturdy. They would be super cute stuck in floral foam they use to arrange flowers in a bowl covered in nuts or something, don’t you think?
It should go without saying that my kids loved these, but I will say it anyways, they thought I was pretty cool. They even helped make them, until I lost all my patience. :)
Well, we’re off to the park to share ours with new friends, nothing like bribing the neighborhood!




















{ 27 comments… read them below or add one }
love them!
Thanks!
So fun Destri! I am so impressed!
They were easy, I just would recommend leaving the ever helpful 2 and 3 year olds out of the equation ;). You do have much more patience than me though…
Five maybe four years old would be fun I think.
that must be the most fun you can have with pie! Perfect for little ones and picniks. I thought key lime pies on a stick was the best, but I might just be mistaken!!!!! BTW the Key lime pie is frozen and dipped completely in chocolate…… I ate one EVERYTIME I was in Key West.
Wha?! How have you never told me about these? We HAVE to try to recreate them! Key lime is my absolute favorite, Seriously we are making these.
my dear if I told you how to make these you’d sue me for an expanding waist line and may be the new cardiac drugs you’d be on!!!!!!!!!!!!
I love this idea! How fun!!!
Thank you! Wish I could take full credit :)
Destri! These are ADORABLE!!!
Thanks Miss Hannah, I have been meaning to email you about Harry Potter, have an extra ticket?
Those turned out so cute. I really think I need to make those.
Why yes, yes you do. Cherry would be so good too.
I totally thought the subject read “Pee on a Stick.” LOL I guess my mind was elsewhere.
LOL, too funny!
great post, love this idea, I got to try these out!
Oh can I come help?!
Very cute! I have been dying to try some out myself.
Ummmm, this may be the best treat ever! Pie on a stick…genius!
Best,
Tina
Cute idea!
Mimi
I love these – super cute. Wish I felt more patient in the kitchen lately!
I couldn’t believe my eyes when I read the title of these, but sure enough pie on a stick. I like it! I’m not a fan of pie per se, but I could be enticed to gobble (if you’ll pardon the Thanksgiving pun) up one or two of these. I’ll be trying these after the holidays. I’m hosting Thanksgiving this year, plus a dinner on Sunday, so I have my hands full at the moment. Thanks for sharing such a novel idea.
OMG..these are absolutely adorable!!! And I’m sure very tasty also.
Do you think Pumpkin pie filling could be partially/mostly cooked to use in these? Family of “must-have-pumpkin pie” people here.
I think that would work fine. And I completely understand the must have pumpkin, I am not even a big fan but for some reason have to have a piece for Thanksgiving!
Hi there,
How long are these little cute pies last? If I make them the day before the party, they should be still ok, right?
Thanks,
Joyce
Yes, they last as long as a pie would!
{ 3 trackbacks }